Appeals court nixes some FCC rules on robocalls

FILE - This Tuesday, Aug. 1, 2017, file photo, shows a call log displayed via an AT&T app on a cellphone in Orlando, Fla. The app helps locate and block fraudulent calls, although some robocalls do get through. A federal appeals court has rolled back rules intended to deter irritating telemarketing robocalls, saying they were too broad. (AP Photo/John Raoux, File)

MENLO PARK, Calif. — A federal appeals court rolled back rules intended to deter irritating telemarketing robocalls, saying they were too broad.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit said that 2015 regulations from the Federal Communications Commission could wrongly classify every smartphone as an autodialing device subject to anti-robocall fines. Those 2015 rules attempted to graft modern definitions onto a 1991 law that predated the iPhone by more than 15 years.

The court also struck down rules that could levy fines on telemarketers who repeatedly call phone numbers reassigned to people who have opted out of such calls.

FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel said in a tweet the ruling was "not good." In a statement, she said, "robocalls will continue to increase unless the FCC does something about it."

The court said the FCC's Obama-era rules were "unreasonably expansive" and could have swept up just about anyone. Its ruling offered the example of someone organizing a get-together and texting 10 people without obtaining their prior consent, which under the rules could subject her to a potential fine of $500 per person.

While it agreed smartphones could be used as autodialers by installing an app, the court said the FCC's rules did not make a clear enough distinction between phones that had downloaded such software and those that hadn't.

In voiding a one-strike rule intended to prevent telemarketers from dialing reassigned numbers more than once, the court found it would be difficult for companies to avoid calling a second time even if they were acting in good faith. It also said the current rule was being abused, citing reports of a new phone customer who waited to receive 900 text alerts intended for a previous subscriber in order to rack up potential penalties before filing a lawsuit.

Lawyer Megan Brown, whose firm Wiley Rein represents Fortune 500 companies sued for such violations, said the court's ruling will "stop the litigation harassment of a bunch of regular companies for crippling damages" when the worst actors behind scams and spoof calls are overseas.

Current FCC Chairman Ajit Pai said in a statement that the ruling would not deter the FCC's stepped up crackdown against illegal robocalls. He cited $200 million in fines the FCC initiated last year against two U.S. firms in so-called "spoofing" scams, in which they disguised their caller IDs in order to sell vacation packages and health insurance.

The FCC is also working to require telecoms companies to report when numbers have been reassigned, and passed rules last year that allow phone companies to proactively block calls that are likely to be fraudulent.

Must Read

Lawmakers tangle anew over Clinton's private...

Sep 8, 2016

A House hearing on State Department record-keeping became a pitched battle over Hillary Clinton's...

3-wheeled electric vehicle set to go on sale this...

Sep 9, 2016

A three-wheeled electric vehicle could be on the road this year in the U.S. and Canada

Lawmaker issues subpoena to FBI for Clinton probe...

Sep 12, 2016

A top House Republican has escalated the GOP's battle with the FBI over the decision not to...

Where to sell your unwanted stuff online and earn...

Dec 28, 2016

If you're cleaning out your closets for the new year, or need some spare cash after the holidays,...

Auto industry's relationship with Trump takes...

Jan 3, 2017

The auto industry's relationship with President-elect Donald Trump took a dramatic turn as Ford...

About Us

The World Insiders brings you exclusive coverage from across the globe in a timely, easy to consume format sourced directly from our regional media partners.

Contact us: sales[at]theworldinsiders.com

Subscribe Now!